Start with the Third Story
The first few sentences can change the direction of a difficult conversation.
"Your people aren't a priority, you need to stop panicking!"
Before I knew it, I was in a difficult conversation.
I remember it well. It was Tuesday, March 17, 2020, and I was having a bad morning.
I was about to stop for coffee when I spotted my wife's car in the middle of an intersection. As I pulled closer, I could see that the collision had deployed all the airbags.
I took a deep breath before getting out of my car. I really didn't know what I was about to see.
The police arrived at nearly the same moment and reached her car before I did. Thankfully, she was okay, but another driver had run a red light and T-boned her car.
So, I never got coffee that morning.
Adrenaline was enough.
When I finally made it to the office, things were chaotic there, too.
If you can place yourself back in mid-March 2020, things were pretty weird. Schools were shutting down, businesses were scrambling, and nobody really knew what was coming next.
Remote work wasn't something we were accustomed to. In our organization, it was generally limited to employees who had laptops.
That morning, I asked one of our IT managers a simple question:
Would it be possible for some of our administrative employees to take their desktop computers home if we needed them to work remotely?
I wasn't asking anyone to make the change. I was exploring whether it was possible and what would be involved.
One of our team members had recently been ill, and I was wondering whether working from home might be a reasonable option.
Within an hour, my phone rang.
One of our HR directors was furious.
I was told that I needed to stop panicking, stop telling IT what to do, and understand that my team wasn't the priority right now.
Given the morning I'd already had, I wasn't particularly well prepared to receive that message.
So, that conversation didn't go well.
Two People, Two Stories
Looking back, I can see that we entered that phone call with very different understandings of what was happening.
My story: I was trying to understand our options. I wasn't making a decsion, and I hadn't asked IT to take any action. I thought I was being proactive.
The HR director's story (as I understood it): I was trying to move my department to the front of the line while the organization was dealing with much bigger problems. My conversation with IT looked like an attempt to work around whatever plans were already underway.
Neither of us entered the conversation particularly curious about the other's perspective.
I felt unfairly accused.
The HR director appeared to believe I was creating panic and confusion.
And we each responded to what we beleived the other person was doing.
The problem was that neither of us had taken the time to establish what was actually happening.
We never really repaired that relationship.
We continued working together, but there was always a strain between us after that conversation.
Looking back, I wonder how differently things might have gone if either of us had started with a little more curiosity about the other's perspective.
We might still have disagreed. There were legitimate questions about priorities, communication, and who should be making decisions.
But instead of trying to understand what was happening, we spent our energy defending what we believed was happening.
And that one conversation shaped how we worked together long after the immediate problem had passed.
The Conversation was Lost Before it Began
In Difficult Conversations, Douglas Stone, Bruce Patton, and Sheila Heen introduce a concept called the Third Story.
Most difficult conversations involve two stories.
There's my version of what happened, and there's yours.
We each have observations, assumptions, intentions, and conclusions that shape our understanding.
The trouble begins when we open the conversation by presenting our interpretation as the truth.
The Third Story offers another starting point.
Imagine someone who understands both perspectives but isn't personally invested in either one. How might that person describe the disagreement?
Not who was right.
Not who caused the problem.
Just what the two people seem to be experiencing differently.
In my situation, a Third Story opening might have sounded something like this:
"I understand you've been asking IT about remote work options for your team. We're working through a lot of competing priorities right now, and I want to make sure we're coordinating those conversations. Can you help me understand what you're considering?"
That wouldn't have required the HR director to agree with my approach.
It wouldn't have prevented us from discussing priorities or clarifying who had authority to make decisions.
But it would have given me an opportunity to explain what I was actually asking.
And perhaps I could have learned something about the work HR was already doing that I hadn't considered.
We might still have disagreed.
But at least we'd have been discussing the same problem.
Start with the Gap, Not the Accusation
The Third Story isn't about avoiding accountability or pretending every perspective is equally accurate.
It's about recognizing that our understanding of a situation may not be the only reasonable one.
Before beginning a difficult conversation, try asking yourself three questions.
What do I actually know happened?
What assumptions am I making about the other person's intentions?
How could I describe the difference between our perspectives without assigning blame?
Sometimes the shift is as simple as replacing an accusation with an oberservation and a question.
Instead of:
"You keep missing deadlines, and it's causing problems for everyone else."
Try:
"We've had several deadlines slip recently. I think we might have different perspectives on what's causing that, and I'd like to understand what's happening."
The expectations hasn't changed.
The problem hasn't disappearred.
But we've created an opportunity to understand the situation before deciding what to do about it. And that's a much better place to begin.
A Quick Reflection
Think about a difficult conversation you've had recently, or one you're putting off.
How would you describe the problem?
How might the other person describe it?
And what would a third person, who understood both perspectives, say was happening?
Before your next difficult conversation, try starting there/
Small shift. Big impact.

