Building Your Team Playbook
Does everyone on your team know what winning looks like?
I told the team, "I really hate losing. But right now, I don't care if we win."
I'll never forget the look on the face of one of my 13-year-old baseball players.
His face was some combination of confusion, horror, and disgust.
I laughed, and so did the team.
It was the spring of 2025, and I was coaching a 13U travel baseball team. I'd divided our season into three phases: Spring Training, Climbing, and Peak. Each phase had its own objectives and measurable goals, including win-loss targets.
I'd explained this concept a few times. But as we approached our first game, hearing their coach say he didn't care about winning was still a little too much for one of them.
Here's what I meant.
There was no championship to win during Spring Training. Our job was to get better.
I wanted players to have opportunities to try positions they were interested in, gain experience in different spots, and develop skills that would make us a strong team late in the season.
Sometimes that meant making a decision that might cost us a game in April but give us a better chance to win in June.
I wasn't telling them that winning didn't matter.
I was telling them that winning today's game wasn't always the same thing as winning the last game of the season.
What Does Winning Actually Mean?
Winning is a complicated thing. In youth sports, I think it tends to carry more weight than it should.
We all know you play to win the game, though what the game really represents is deeper than a single outcome.
On of my favorite thought leaders, Simon Sinek, explores the idea in his book The Infinite Game.
Baseball games are finite. There's a scoreboard, as set of rules, and a defined endpoint which determines a winner and a loser.
But developing young athletes is different. Can you win at developing talent over your career? How could we ever measure and compare how much joy your players experienced playing for your team? Development is an infinite game.
As coaches, we have to operate in both worlds.
We want to compete. We want to win. But we also want to build skills, confidence, character, and a love for the game that will outlast the current season.
The challenge comes when those goals compete.
It's easy to say player development matters. It's much harder to demonstrate that commitment when the game is tied in the last inning and a less experienced player is on the mound.
It's times like those when clarity around your team's purpose matters most, to your players, the parents, and your fellow coaches.
That's why I believe every team needs a playbook that goes beyond Xs and Os.
Not just a plan for how we'll play the game, but a shared understanding of why we're here, what success looks like, and how we'll pursue it together.
Six Questions for Building Your Team Playbook
Candidly, this model might seem beneath you. It's deceptively simple, and as such, I think it's an invaluable resource to a coaching staff when navigating tough decisions, player feedback, and conversations with parents.
The Advantage by Patrick Lencioni is undoubtably the most influential business book in my life. It set the course for nearly all the work I now do and has changed the way I look at group dynamics.
In that book, Lencioni introduces six critical questions that help leadership teams create organizational clarity.
I've found that the same questions translate remarkably well to coaching
1.Why do we exist? What's our purpose, beyond winning games?
2. How do we behave? What do we reward? What do we not allow?
3. What do we do? As simple as it sounds.
4. How will we succeed? What is our strategy? How will we use our strengths?
5. What's most important right now? Where should we focus our attention?
6. Who must do what? What responsibilities belong to coaches, players, and parents?
These aren't questions that require a weekend retreat or a complicated planning process.
But they do require intentional responses, and a few hours with your coaching staff.
The most crucial question is the first: Why do we exist?
While it might sound like an existential philosophy question, it's simply, what is the purpose of this team?
For us, the purpose was to develop high-school ready skills for a community travel team and to create lasting memories and friendships.
Notice that winning X-number of games is not present here (thought it could be). Our purpose was not finite.
My three-phase approach was largely an exercise in answering that fifth question: What's most important right now?

During Spring Training, it was development and opportunity. During Climbing, we increasingly focused on translating that development into better team performance. And during Peak, our emphasis shifted towards competing at our highest level.
The overall purpose hadn't changed. But our priorities, expectations, and decisions evolved as the season progressed.
Because we communicated this consistently, we had something to return to when the scoreboard tempted us to lose sight of our priorities.

Your Players Are Watching What You Do
You might be thinking that writing down a purpose or a set of values feels touchy-feely or unnecessary.
I've seen plenty of coaches talk about developing players, building character, and being a good teammate without going through a process like this.
Most of us know the right things to say already.
But what happens when there's a gap?
We tell players that mistakes are part of learning, then get frustrated when someone makes an error.
We talk about sportsmanship, then overlook poor behavior from our most talented player.
We say everyone has a role, then fail to help the players who aren't getting playing time understand how they contribute to the team.
Our players notice these things.
And when our actions contradict our words, they learn which expectations really matter.
The real team playbook isn't what we say at the beginning of the season. It's what we consistently reinforce throughout it.
That's one reason I believe this clarity matters so much.
When we've agreed on what success looks like, we have something to guide our decisions when emotions are high.
Of course, this doesn't imply every decision gets easier. It just means we're less likely to lose focus on our priorities simply because a moment is uncomfortable.
Take It to the Dugout
While I think all six responses will provide the most value, I want to give you a simpler approach.
Before your next season, gather your coaching staff and work through three questions:
What would make this season successful beyond our win-loss record?
Be specific. What do you want your players to learn, experience, or accomplish? What would make you proud of this team even if your final record isn't what you hoped?
What's most important at different points this season?
Does your approach to development, experimentation, playing time, and competition change as the season progresses? If so, how?
What decisions will we need to make to support these priorities?
If development matters, how will you create opportunities for players to grow? If teamwork matters, what behaviors will you recognize and correct? If competing for a championship is a goal, how will you prepare the team for that moment?
You don't need a lengthy document. Start with a few clear commitments your coaches support and can explain to your players.
Once you have those responses, it's time to communicate them.
The power is in repeating the message. Prevailing wisdom tells us that people need to hear things seven times before they actually hear them.
Maybe that explains the challenge of parenting.
The key here is defining what you're aiming at, then communicating it relentlessly. With your words and your actions.
The Playbook is More Than a Plan
Looking back, I still laugh when I remember that player's face.
I understand his reaction. At 13, winning the game in front of you feels ike the whole point.
And to be fair, there are plenty of adults who see it the same way.
But coaching gives us an opportunity to see something bigger.
We can teach them that progress matters, that preparation has a purpose, and that sometimes the best decision for the team isn't the one that produces the best immediate return.
Most importantly, we can show them what it looks like to make decisions based on what we've said matters.
The scoreboard tells us who won the game. But it doesn't always tell us whether we accomplished what we set out to do.
P.S. For those wondering, we finished the 2025 season with a 24-17 record but fell short of a league championship. While that was more wins than the team had in the prior three seasons combined, what I'm most proud of was how much the boys grew as ballplayers and teammates.

