A Conversation I Wish I Could Have Back
“You can’t fire me for being pregnant.”
I did not have that phrase on my new manager bingo card.
To be quite clear, I was NOT firing anyone at all, let alone for being pregnant.
It was my first year of managing people. I'd hired Krissy three months earlier and didn’t know she was pregnant. I found out when she told me she was due in about a month and wanted to know how our benefits worked…
So, I went to our HR Director and asked that question.
The answer was not very helpful.
Our HR Director informed me she was not yet eligible for FMLA and we couldn't guarantee her job would be held, and I was to tell her that we’d do our best to keep a position, but it was not promised.
So that's what I did... and that conversation didn’t go well.
This was when Krissy said that I couldn't fire her for being pregnant.
I was caught off guard by her response. I tried to clarify, empathize, and explain. I don't think she heard a word I said.
Trust was severely damaged.
What should have been an exciting time in her life had suddenly become a source of uncertainty about her livelihood.
What happened next only made things worse.
Frustrated by our conversation, Krissy went to speak with HR herself. The same HR Director told her while she wasn’t technically eligible for FMLA leave, we would honor it and keep her job protected. Hooray… right?
Not so much.
A few weeks later, Krissy had the baby, and during her leave, the employee whose departure had created Krissy's opening rejoined our team.
The good news was that we'd grown enough to keep both employees when Krissy returned. I told Krissy that, but it was obvious she was skeptical.
Krissy and I never restored the trust that was lost. A few months later, without any conversation, she stayed later than normal, packed up all her stuff, and left the role. No notice. No goodbyes. Just gone.
For a long time, I looked back on that experience with frustration. I was a new manager, following the direction I'd been given, trying to navigate a situation I didn't understand.
But the older I've gotten, the more I've come to recognize something uncomfortable.
I wasn't responsible for every part of what happened. But I was responsible for how I led through it.
This story's purpose is not to “blame HR” – I know that’s an easy reflex. The purpose is to share my own weakness and ignorance in understanding how I contributed to this outcome, and how to lead people well despite the challenges.
Two of my favorite resources around this topic are the books Extreme Ownership and Difficult Conversations. I wish I had them back then, and I’m certain that there are new and seasoned leaders who can still benefit from their wisdom.
So what lessons are to be applied to Krissy’s story?
1. From Extreme Ownership, leaders must take complete responsibility for everything in their world without excuses or blame.
Sure, I can blame others for giving me bad instructions or making the excuse that I was too green to know that policy is not always rigid. While I can't know whether a stronger relationship would have changed the outcome, I do know I hadn't done enough to build the kind of trust that might have helped us navigate a difficult situation together.
2. From Difficult Conversations, there are typically three conversations happening at once: what happened (facts), feelings, and our identities.
When I shared the news about Krissy’s job not being protected, I thought I was having a conversation about policy. Krissy was hearing that her job was at risk because she was having a baby. And when she accused me of trying to fire her for being pregnant, I was focused on defending my intentions instead of understanding her fears. We weren't having the same conversation, and I didn't recognize it.
3. From Extreme Ownership, following instructions isn't the same as taking ownership.
The painful lesson here was recognizing that I could have asked more questions instead of simply accepting the answer I was given. With an accounting background, I tend to be a rule follower. What I've learned over the years is that policies aren't always as rigid as we assume, and good leaders need the curiosity and courage to explore what options might be available.
4. From Difficult Conversations, problem solving comes after understanding.
Ultimately, Krissy did receive job-protected leave, so the policy problem was solved. But the relationship problem wasn't. Even if I hadn't built enough trust before that first conversation, I still had opportunities to repair it afterward. We never worked through what had happened or how she felt when her predecessor returned. If I had this to do over, I hope I would be able to help her share her perspective, acknowledge the feelings, and establish the trust required to sustain the relationship.
I wish I'd understood these lessons when I was a new manager.
Maybe the outcome would have been the same, but I wish I had been better prepared to handle the moment.
If you're lucky, your employer might sponsor some form of leadership training, but often, these are centered around performance, discipline, or policy.
The moments that shape someone's trust in a leader for years rarely match the training. They show up in ordinary conversations, unexpected reactions, and decisions we don't feel equipped to make.
And sometimes, we don't recognize how important they were until long after they're over.
Think about a difficult conversation from your own leadership experience.
What did you believe the problem was at the time?
Looking back, what might you have missed?
PS – "Krissy", if this somehow makes its way to you, I'm sorry. I wish I'd had the skill and awareness to navigate that situation differently.

